Below is a list of feature films that Shawn Hatosy has starred in. They are listed in reverse-chronological order, with the most recent ones last. Click on the titles to read more about each project individually.
| 1995 | Home for the Holidays | Counter Boy |
| 1995 | Inflammable | Quentin Vale |
| 1996 | Double Jeopardy | Derek Kaminski |
| 1996 | No Way Home | Sean |
| 1997 | All Over Me | Gus |
| 1997 | Inventing the Abbotts | Victor |
| 1997 | Niagara, Niagara | Lead High School Punk |
| 1997 | In & Out | Jack |
| 1997 | The Postman | Billy |
| 1998 | The Faculty | Stan Rosado |
| 1999 | The Joyriders | Cam |
| 1999 | Witness Protection | Sean Batton |
| 1999 | Outside Providence | Tim Dunphy |
| 1999 | Simpatico | Young Vinnie Webb |
| 1999 | Anywhere but Here | Benny |
| 2000 | Down to You | Eddie Hicks |
| 2000 | Borstal Boy | Brendan Behan |
| 2001 | Tangled | David Klein |
| 2002 | John Q. | Mitch Quigley |
| 2003 | A Guy Thing | Jim |
| 2003 | Soldier’s Girl | Justin Fisher |
| 2003 | The Cooler | Mikey Lootz |
| 2003 | 11:14 | Duffy Nichols |
| 2003 | Dallas 362 | Rusty |
| 2004 | The Winning Season | Adult Joseph Stoshack |
| 2005 | Swimmers | Clyde Tyler |
| 2005 | Faith of My Fathers | John McCain |
| 2005 | Little Athens | Carter |
| 2006 | Alpha Dog | Elvis Schmidt |
| 2006 | Factory Girl | Syd Pepperman |
| 2007 | Nobel Son | Thaddeus James |
| 2008 | Familiar Strangers | Brian Worthington |
| 2008 | The Apostles | Peter McBride |
| 2008 | The Lazarus Project | Ricky Garvey |
| 2009 | Public Enemies | FBI Agent John Madala |
| 2009 | Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans | Detective Armand Benoit |
| 2011 | Street Kings 2: Motor City | Detective Dan Sullivan |
| 2018 | Mountain Rest | Bascolm |
| 2019 | The Bygone | Paris |
| 2022 | Mosquito | Humphrey Bowls |
| 2024 | Unstoppable | Tom Brands |
| 2026 | Ready or Not 2: Here I Come | Titus Danforth |